WordPress plugin comparison
Theme My Login vs WP-Members Membership Plugin
Theme My Login
by Jeff Farthing
50K+ installs3.7
WP-Members Membership Plugin
by Chad Butler
50K+ installs4.6
At a glance
- Both have 50K+ active installs.
- On a typical day, WP-Members Membership Plugin is downloaded about 1,223 times, Theme My Login about 450.
- WP-Members Membership Plugin is rated higher: 4.6 out of 5 from 272 reviews, against 3.7 from 460 reviews.
- WP-Members Membership Plugin was updated more recently: Oct 27, 2026, against Oct 13, 2026 for Theme My Login.
- Theme My Login resolves more of its support threads: 100% in the last two months, against 40% for WP-Members Membership Plugin.
- Both are tested up to WordPress 7.1.4.
Line by line
WP-Members Membership Plugin leads on 4 of 6 comparable lines.
| Metric | Theme My Login | WP-Members Membership Plugin |
|---|---|---|
| Popular rank | #703 | #749 |
| Active installs | 50K+ | 50K+ |
| Downloads, last 30 days | 39.3K | 69.5K |
| Rating | 3.7(460) | 4.6(272) |
| Support threads resolved | 100% | 40% |
| Tested up to | 7.1.4 | 7.1.4 |
| Search multiplier | ×1.07 | ×1.35 |
| Last release | 28 days ago | 14 days ago |
| Requires PHP | – | – |
From WordPress.org's public data, refreshed every night. Downloads are WordPress.org's official daily figures for the last 30 days.
Tags they share
More comparisons
- Theme My Login vs Custom Login Page Customizer
- Theme My Login vs Erident Custom Login Page & Dashboard
- Theme My Login vs LoginPress
- Theme My Login vs Easy Hide Login
- WP-Members Membership Plugin vs Limit Login Attempts
- WP-Members Membership Plugin vs WPS Limit Login
- WP-Members Membership Plugin vs Login for Google Apps by WPAuth
- WP-Members Membership Plugin vs WP Limit Login Attempts
Is one of these yours?
Track your plugin against its rivals every day: rank, installs, downloads, ratings and their releases, with alerts when anything moves.
Start free