WordPress plugin comparison
Magic Login vs Theme My Login
At a glance
- Theme My Login has more active installs: 50K+, against 3K+ for Magic Login.
- On a typical day, Theme My Login is downloaded about 450 times, Magic Login about 122.
- Magic Login is rated higher: 4.8 out of 5 from 26 reviews, against 3.7 from 460 reviews.
- Theme My Login was updated more recently: Oct 13, 2026, against Aug 11, 2026 for Magic Login.
- Both are tested up to WordPress 7.1.4.
- Theme My Login has been around longer: since 2009, against 2021 for Magic Login.
Line by line
Theme My Login leads on 5 of 6 comparable lines.
| Metric |  Magic Login |  Theme My Login |
|---|---|---|
| Popular rank | #3,770 | #703 |
| Active installs | 3K+ | 50K+ |
| Downloads, last 30 days | 3.2K | 39.3K |
| Rating | 4.8(26) | 3.7(460) |
| Support threads resolved | 100% | 100% |
| Tested up to | 7.1.4 | 7.1.4 |
| Search multiplier | ×0.86 | ×1.07 |
| Last release | 3 months ago | 28 days ago |
| Requires PHP | 7.4 | – |
From WordPress.org's public data, refreshed every night. Downloads are WordPress.org's official daily figures for the last 30 days.
Tags they share
More comparisons
Is one of these yours?
Track your plugin against its rivals every day: rank, installs, downloads, ratings and their releases, with alerts when anything moves.
Start free